Douglas Stewart Carter, 71, is ordered released on bail after spending 41 years on death row for the 1985 murder of Eva Olesen. Multiple outlets report that new DNA analysis finds he is not a match to biological material tied to the case. The Utah Supreme Court also cites serious police misconduct in proceedings related to his conviction.
The conviction is described as lacking physical evidence linking Carter to the crime scene. CBS and ABC Australia say the original case relied heavily on a confession that Carter later said was coerced and on witness testimony that later recanted. BBC similarly notes that Carter consistently maintained his innocence. While some family members of the victim raise concerns about his release on bail, defense attorneys say they are pursuing further relief.
A retrial is scheduled for 2027, according to Times of India, with an aim that all charges could ultimately be dismissed depending on the court’s outcome.