Starbucks faces a U.S. class action lawsuit alleging that eight protein beverages marketed as “sugar-free” contain substantial sugar, with some drinks alleged to have up to 21 grams per serving. The complaint, filed in federal court in Seattle by Hagens Berman on behalf of three consumers in California, New York and Washington, argues the naming and marketing are misleading and violate U.S. labeling regulations.

Outlets report that the suit focuses on how the drinks are labeled “sugar-free” on cafe menus and Starbucks’ website, even though menus reportedly list nonzero sugar amounts that vary by drink size and flavor. The allegation includes comparisons to snack products such as Kit Kat or Reese’s peanut butter cups, depending on the outlet, to underscore the claimed sugar levels.

Starbucks denies the allegations, saying it does not add sugar to the drinks and that any sugar comes from protein-boosted milk it uses. Starbucks also says it uses sugar-free syrup for flavoring and points to what it describes as consistent disclosures of nutritional information across menus and marketing, saying it intends to “vigorously defend” itself. The lawsuit seeks damages and asks the court to stop Starbucks from using the “sugar-free” label on products that contain sugar.