A new three-part Hulu docuseries, “Swipe Right on the Devil,” revisits the 2017 murder of Sydney Loofe. The series describes how a Tinder date led to a small group portrayed as a cult, and how the killing is linked in the account to claims about forming a coven of witches.

Both outlets frame the release as an examination of the events surrounding the death and the wider allegations of satanic ritual and witchcraft. TIME also emphasizes that the series marks the first time since the murder that Loofe’s family speaks out publicly through the docuseries, highlighting their perspective as a key part of the reporting. The New York Post, in contrast, foregrounds the streaming hook and the graphic, sensational framing of the path from dating to the group and killing.