Canada-based research is casting doubt on a widely circulated bond-market theory that China disguises the true extent of its ownership of U.S. debt by holding large amounts of securities through Canadian accounts. The reports say analysts and bond-market watchers had pointed to Canada’s rising holdings of U.S. bonds, alongside China’s declining positions, as supporting evidence for what has been described as a “conspiracy.”

Financial Post and Bloomberg both describe research from National Bank (NBF) that argues the pattern has more straightforward explanations. While the theory suggests China’s holdings are being routed through Canada, the Canadian bank’s analysis, as presented in both outlets, concludes that there are logical reasons for the observed figures other than concealment. The coverage focuses on the interpretation of bond-holding data and differences among market participants over what the numbers imply.