Victor Osimhen is at the centre of a debate after Galatasaray defeat Lille 4-2 in the UEFA Champions League, following his selection as man of the match. Former Turkish referee Ahmet Çakar publicly challenges that decision, arguing that the award should have gone to others instead.

Across the two outlets, Çakar’s position is presented as a critique of the Man of the Match choice rather than of the match result itself. He points to three Galatasaray teammates—named in both reports—as players he believes made greater contributions. The coverage frames the disagreement as a matter of fairness in awarding the honour, with both articles emphasising that Osimhen scored Galatasaray’s first goal against Lille and still, in Çakar’s view, did not merit the top individual recognition.

While both sources draw on the same core claim from Çakar, their emphasis differs slightly: one focuses on the question of whether Osimhen’s award is justified, while the other adds a direct characterisation that the decision is “unfair,” alongside the listing of the other deserving players.