Two advice columns, published by UK tabloids, address a reader’s situation: they say they have fallen for an old friend after a casual, friends-with-benefits arrangement, but the friend does not return the same feelings. The reader frames the relationship as something they hoped could turn into a committed partnership, despite recognising signals they “should have seen” earlier.

Both outlets present the issue as a relationship guidance case centred on navigating unreciprocated feelings and the end (or shift) of a casual arrangement. The framing focuses less on specific individuals and more on general advice—how to respond after emotions change, manage disappointment, and consider whether the relationship should continue in its prior form.

While both stories share the same core premise, they differ slightly in emphasis in their headlines and descriptions: one column foregrounds that the advice is explicitly “Dear Coleen,” while the other stresses the breakup of the friends-with-benefits dynamic and the need for Coleen’s guidance as the relationship shifts away from ambiguity.