The Allahabad High Court quashes criminal proceedings against a fertility specialist accused of cheating a patient after an IVF treatment fails to result in pregnancy. The court holds that failure of an IVF procedure, on its own, does not amount to “cheating” under Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code. It says a cheating case cannot proceed merely because a medical outcome was not achieved or an agreement was not fulfilled; prosecutors must show dishonest intention from the start.
The complaint, filed under Section 156(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, alleges that the patient was assured his wife would conceive and was charged about Rs 3.5 lakh, but the wife did not become pregnant and the doctor did not refund the money on request. The doctor argues that IVF does not offer guaranteed success because results depend on multiple physiological factors, and fees represent professional charges rather than property obtained through deception.
Across coverage, the focus remains on the court’s legal reasoning: IVF outcomes are not treated as automatic evidence of fraud, and establishing dishonest intent at the beginning of the transaction is presented as essential.