India’s Supreme Court tags and lists new petitions challenging Section 16 of the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023, which grants civil and criminal immunity for actions taken in the course of official duties. The court brings the cases together with an existing plea raising similar legal concerns.
The petitions focus on perceived imbalance in accountability, arguing that immunity for Election Commissioners is broader and effectively lifelong compared with protections for other high constitutional office-holders. One plea, brought by RJD MP Manoj Jha, contends that the statutory framework creates a structural anomaly—for instance, contrasting immunity for Election Commissioners with the possibility of prosecution for the President after leaving office, and comparing protections to those applicable to Members of Parliament and senior judges.
Outlets report the same core development—issuance of court directions seeking responses from the Centre and Election Commission, and the listing of the matter—while emphasizing different details. One source foregrounds the court’s decision to tag fresh petitions to an existing case, while others highlight the Supreme Court’s request for the Centre and Election Commission’s response and the role of Manoj Jha in initiating the challenge.