“Jimmy” is a biographical drama that follows James Stewart, focusing on his military service during World War II and the period immediately after. Across reviews, KJ Apa’s performance is highlighted as a central element, with both outlets pointing to his ability to embody key aspects of Stewart’s on-screen presence.
However, the critiques diverge on how effectively the film uses its subject matter. The Hollywood Reporter frames the movie as dutiful but slow-moving, suggesting the biography does not fully overcome its straightforward presentation. The Guardian, while acknowledging that Apa offers a surprisingly solid performance and a reasonable imitation, characterizes the film as too simple and misses opportunities, describing it as corny and overly direct.
Overall, both sources agree on the film’s basic premise—Stewart’s wartime service as the core narrative—while differing in emphasis: one stresses pacing and overall engagement, the other stresses missed dramatic potential and the bluntness of its approach.