The Bombay High Court allows a 54-year-old woman from Nashik to pursue surrogacy, after an earlier rejection based on statutory age limits. Both reports say the court directs authorities to treat the couple’s eligibility in a way that does not automatically prevent the intended parents from proceeding when only one partner exceeds the age threshold.
In context, the challenge centres on the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 and an upper age limit used to deny an eligibility certificate. The Times of India and Free Press Journal both describe the court’s approach as purposive, emphasizing protection of surrogate mothers and the rights of children, while also assessing the couple as a “composite unit.” Free Press Journal adds that the husband was 53 and cites constitutional arguments about reproductive autonomy, alongside the Union of India’s defence that advanced parental age can affect long-term caregiving and psychological well-being for children. The differing emphasis is procedural and legal—Free Press Journal highlights the directive to issue an eligibility certificate and the arguments exchanged—while Times of India focuses on the purposive interpretation and the eligibility concept.