Warner Bros. is developing a remake of the 1998 romantic comedy “You’ve Got Mail,” with Jason Orley attached to direct, multiple outlets report. While the original starred Tom Hanks and Meg Ryan and was directed by Nora Ephron, details about the new film’s plot have not yet been announced.

The reporting focuses on whether a modern remake can feel meaningful. Fast Company argues that the movie is “un-remake-able” because the technology, social norms and economics that shaped the story now feel outdated—particularly the AOL-era premise behind the title and the way younger audiences may no longer recognize that context. The Guardian, in contrast, frames the project as something that could be justified because the original clearly reflects its age and its central premise—email, books, and romance—has shifted over time.

Across the coverage, outlets emphasize the same starting point—an almost 28-year-old dial-up and email-era romcom—while differing in their implied assessment of what a reboot would need to overcome to land with contemporary viewers.