“Student of the Year: After Dark,” a web series spun off from Karan Johar’s film franchise, is now streaming on JioHotstar. Across outlets, the show’s central focus on Shanaya Kapoor’s performance is repeatedly highlighted, with attention also given to its mystery-thriller premise and episode structure.

Free Press Journal and NDTV both describe Shanaya Kapoor’s OTT debut and give mixed critical responses, though they differ in emphasis. Free Press Journal’s review presents the series as Shanaya’s “arrival” and points to her dual-role performance, while also laying out the plot: a shocking live stream, a victim found in water, and a twin sister infiltrating a school competition to uncover hidden secrets. NDTV’s reviews frame the thriller as exhausting or “a mess,” citing weak writing and limited payoff, despite acknowledging Shanaya’s no-glam approach. Other Free Press Journal coverage also notes mixed audience reactions on X, with some users praising Shanaya’s acting while others call it unbearable.