NASCAR’s Rookie of the Year award faces criticism after Corey Heim says the honor loses meaning when there is only one eligible candidate. According to Yahoo Sports, Heim frames the situation as a “participation trophy,” pointing to Connor Zilisch being the sole 2026 Rookie of the Year contender.

Motorsport.com adds context by comparing Zilisch’s rookie performance with other Rookie of the Year winners. The outlet describes Zilisch’s season as one he would like to forget, noting he earned the Rookie of the Year trophy as the only candidate. Motorsport.com also contrasts Zilisch’s overall Cup Series results with Corey Heim’s two-race wins as a part-time driver, while stating he was not eligible for the award.

Across both outlets, the focus is not just on Zilisch’s unopposed win, but on what Heim and Motorsport.com portray as the competitiveness—or lack of it—around the Rookie of the Year process.