Producers and Disney executives recalled being alarmed by Johnny Depp’s unconventional portrayal of Jack Sparrow during the making of Pirates of the Caribbean, according to an excerpt from a new biography. Multiple outlets say the concerns focused on how the character was presented, with the reported questions centering on whether Depp’s version was “gay” and “incredibly drunk.”
The Hollywood Reporter presents an exclusive excerpt describing the producers’ reaction as shock and pitching the idea that they had to “trust” Depp’s approach. Both the Daily Mail and Mail Online describe the same biography and similarly emphasize the initial executive discomfort with Depp’s interpretation.
One additional point appears in the New York Post, which includes franchise context, saying Pirates of the Caribbean has earned more than $4.5 billion worldwide across five films. Across coverage, the differences mainly relate to framing and how much broader franchise background is included, rather than the core claim that executives were surprised by Depp’s take on the role.