The Philippine Coast Guard’s spokesperson Jay Tarriela rejects a Chinese scholar’s claim that Ayungin (Second Thomas) Shoal is Chinese territory, arguing the disputed feature sits within the Philippines’ exclusive economic zone (EEZ). Both outlets report that Tarriela pushes back against the academic assertion, framing the issue within the longstanding South China Sea dispute.

In the Philippines’ responses, the emphasis differs slightly. One report highlights Tarriela’s core point that Ayungin Shoal lies in the Philippines’ EEZ. The other adds more context about the Chinese scholar’s argument, including claims about “fundamental differences” on the dispute and references to China’s conduct in defending what it describes as its territorial integrity, using an example tied to Second Thomas Shoal.

Together, the articles underscore ongoing information exchanges amid tensions in the South China Sea, with Philippine officials disputing Chinese academic characterizations of sovereignty and territorial control around Ayungin (Second Thomas) Shoal.