Alan Milburn calls for major changes to England’s approach to mental health support for young people, including ending the use of mental-health sick notes and defunding private ADHD and autism clinics. He argues this would tackle what he describes as a “cash for diagnosis” culture, where some independent clinics provide diagnoses and patients then rely on those labels to access support.
Both outlets frame Milburn’s remarks as aimed at closing gaps that they say have allowed profit-driven diagnosis practices to replace broader assessments and earlier help. They also connect the plan to concerns that, for some young people, a diagnosis becomes the main route to services rather than a step within a wider system of support.
The two reports largely agree on the core thrust: Milburn’s criticism of private clinic incentives and his call for funding decisions and eligibility rules to be tightened. Differences are mainly in emphasis—one foregrounds the end to sick notes for young people and the defunding claim, while the other leads with the potential loss of NHS funding for private ADHD clinics.