Actor Matthew Rhys says a poorly judged joke during a James Bond casting meeting derailed his chance to become 007 in the early 2000s. Rhys, who was among those considered to succeed Pierce Brosnan, recounts being called to meet the Broccoli family at offices overlooking London’s Green Park to discuss the role.

According to Rhys, the conversation initially touched on whether he had read Ian Fleming’s “Casino Royale.” But things shifted when the panel asked what he would do differently with Bond. He says he suggested “limp” as a “terrible joke” and then added another idea for an eye patch. He describes the response as going quiet, after which he “fell apart,” and ultimately concluded that he was not going to get the part.

All outlets presented the same core story and agree that Daniel Craig went on to play Bond, with “Casino Royale” cited as his debut. The reporting primarily differs in emphasis and wording—some focus on Rhys missing the role, while others frame it as reflection on the “terrible joke” and its impact on the audition.