Manchester City’s 1-0 win over Manchester United at Old Trafford stands, but the Premier League referees’ body Pro Ref admits VAR made an “error of judgement” in awarding Erling Haaland’s goal.
Several outlets report that the strike was initially ruled offside on the pitch, then overturned after VAR review. Pro Ref says the key issue involved Enzo Fernandez’s position: VAR determined Haaland was onside, but failed to recognize the likely impact of Fernandez being in an offside position during the attack. The statement indicates an on-field review should have been recommended in that situation.
Reports also note the context of the match, including Phil Foden being shown a straight red card in the first half for kicking Bruno Fernandes, and that United officials raised concerns after the goal. Multiple articles state Pro Ref contacted Manchester United with an apology and that a formal review will be carried out. Outlets vary slightly in emphasis—some foreground the VAR “wrongly awarded” wording, while others cite the “error of judgement” phrasing—but they align on the same admitted officiating mistake and the need for review.
