Aaron Judge is left off the New York Yankees’ roster for the American League Wild Card Series against the Boston Red Sox, according to multiple reports. The decision follows his absence from the lineup after the Yankees placed him on the injured list with a calf strain in mid-September.

The outlets agree on the basic medical and roster facts, but add different details about timing and Judge’s response. Yahoo Sports reports Judge has been sidelined since Sept. 18 and that he takes live batting practice ahead of the series in an effort to persuade the Yankees’ medical staff and manager Aaron Boone. Fox News and The Athletic frame the situation as Judge being among several injured players trying to return before the postseason begins. Yardbarker and other reports cite Boone indicating the Yankees are preparing without him. Yahoo Sports also notes Giancarlo Stanton is included despite an earlier calf-related injury, and that Judge’s goal is to be ready by Game 1, even as the team plans forward without him.