The Employment Relations Authority (ERA) rules that Bidfood unjustifiably dismisses its HR manager Natalie Plows following remarks described as racist. The ERA’s decision finds the termination was not warranted and that Bidfood’s handling of the matter did not meet the requirements of a fair process.

Both outlets report that the ERA acknowledges the concerns about Plows’ conduct, but focuses on problems in the disciplinary steps taken by Bidfood. Stuff adds detail that the ERA identifies serious flaws in Bidfood’s disciplinary process and reports the outcome as an award of $35,000. NZ Herald similarly emphasises that the dismissal itself is ruled unjustified, while not centring the same monetary figure.

Taken together, the coverage highlights that the case turns on the ERA’s assessment of fairness and procedure, even as the underlying conduct is described as involving a “typical Asian” remark.