Republicans’ efforts to use mid-decade congressional redistricting to gain or retain House seats appear to have backfired in Tuesday night’s midterm elections, as Democrats held onto seats and expanded their presence. Several of the races targeted through new or redrawn districts did not deliver the gains Republicans expected, with outlet coverage pointing to a broader Democratic surge.

PBS NewsHour and the Washington Examiner describe the redistricting strategy as aimed at helping Republicans maintain the House majority, but failing to flip the intended Democratic-held seats. Fox News highlights multiple state redistricting efforts, saying they backfired across battleground and safe GOP areas. Mother Jones attributes the strategy’s failure to an ambitious mid-decade plan tied to Donald Trump’s political position, while Newsweek frames the flop around why the GOP’s expectations were not met.

Overall, the outlets broadly agree on the central outcome: Republican redistricting efforts did not translate into the midterm edge they sought, even as they differ in emphasis—some focus on targeted seat losses, others on specific states, and others on the political context behind the maps.