Hong Kong’s judiciary says High Court judge Wilson Chan Ka-shun will be reprimanded again for plagiarism after being found to have copied substantial parts of a judgment. The issue stems from a case he handled in 2024, where an appeal court concluded that he used “impermissible judicial copying,” lifting nearly 95% of a previous judgment or substantial sections taken from the defendant’s counsel’s submissions, including parts described as opening and closing arguments. The judiciary says Chief Justice Andrew Cheung Kui-nung will issue a “serious reprimand” for a second time since 2023 and will also require the judge to undergo training. Multiple outlets report this is at least the third known plagiarism incident involving Chan within about three years, following earlier reprimands. The latest development comes after a Court of Appeal ruling dated July 15 became public, and an associated order for a retrial was reported following the appellate court’s findings. The judiciary statement focuses on the need for corrective measures and compliance with judicial standards, while the parties’ underlying dispute proceeds through the ordered retrial.
Hong Kong High Court judge Wilson Chan faces further reprimand for plagiarism
Hong Kong’s judiciary says High Court judge Wilson Chan Ka-shun will be reprimanded again for plagiarism after being found to have copied substantial parts of a judgment. The issue stems from a case h...
- Hong Kong High Court judge Wilson Chan Ka-shun is set to receive a further “serious reprimand” from Chief Justice Andrew Cheung Kui-nung.
- The Court of Appeal finds Chan engaged in “impermissible judicial copying” in a case he oversaw in 2024.
- Reporting indicates Chan copied almost 95% of material from prior work or from the defendant’s counsel’s submissions, including opening and closing arguments.
- The judiciary says Chan will be required to undergo training; it is described as a second reprimand since 2023.
- Outlets describe the incident as at least the third known plagiarism case involving Chan over roughly three years.
A High Court judge with a history of plagiarism will be reprimanded for yet another incident in which he copied large parts of a party’s submissions into his judgement. The Judiciary said in a reply to HKFP on Wednesday that High Court Judge Wilson Chan will receive a “serious reprimand” from Chief Justice Andrew Cheung […]
1 hour agoHong Kong’s chief justice will once again reprimand a High Court judge and require him to undergo training after he was found to have plagiarised large swathes of submissions for a judgment, in what is at least the sixth instance of extensive copying. In a response to the South China Morning Post on Wednesday, the judiciary said that Wilson Chan Ka-shun would face a “serious reprimand” from Chief Justice Andrew Cheung Kui-nung for the second time since 2023. The judiciary said that in light of...
6 hours agoA Hong Kong High Court judge previously reprimanded for plagiarism has been found to have done so again, after an appeal court determined that almost 95 per cent of a previous judgment was lifted from the defendant’s counsel. In a ruling dated July 15, which came to light on Tuesday, a panel of three Court of Appeal judges found that Mr Justice Wilson Chan Ka-shun had engaged in “impermissible judicial copying” in a case he oversaw in 2024. The original case stemmed from a dispute between Nam...
1 day agoA Hong Kong judge previously reprimanded for plagiarism has been caught copying again, making it the third known incident over the past three years. High Court judge Wilson Chan was accused by the plaintiff in a case he presided over of lifting the defendant’s opening and closing arguments. Those paragraphs comprised 95 per cent of […]
1 day ago
Hitler’s Austrian birthplace reopened as police station to deter neo-Nazi pilgrimages
Austria reopens Adolf Hitler’s birthplace in Braunau am Inn as a police station, converting the house after years of deb...
US to announce nuclear agreement with Saudi Arabia amid Iran tensions
The United States plans to announce a nuclear cooperation agreement with Saudi Arabia, according to reports from multipl...
Lalit Modi says he will return to India after SAFEMA tribunal verdict
Lalit Modi says he will return to India in the near future after a major legal ruling. According to NDTV and Times of In...