The contractor hired to renovate the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool says problems in its work and repair plan, rather than vandalism, are responsible for the newly installed “American flag blue” lining peeling and tearing. Documents reviewed by the New York Times indicate Atlantic Industrial Coatings pointed to planning and execution failures that led to the liner layers not bonding properly and to blistering and loosening.

President Donald Trump has repeatedly claimed the damage came from vandals using sharp tools. Other reporting tied those claims to subsequent criminal charges brought by Trump’s attorney in Washington, D.C., Jeanine Pirro, which were later dropped. The Atlantic Industrial Coatings documents described issues such as insufficient primer application and the use of chemicals that were not compatible with each other in the liner repair process.

Across outlets, the focus centers on whether the damage stemmed from sabotage or from the renovation itself, with both sources emphasizing that the contractor’s own documented findings contradict the administration’s vandalism narrative. The reports also note that the renovation contract was awarded through a no-bid process.