Nigeria’s ruling party says a proposed “production subsidy” for crude allocated to local refineries—recently advocated by presidential candidate Atiku Abubakar—failed when a similar idea was tried under former President Olusegun Obasanjo.

Senior special assistant to President Bola Tinubu on digital and new media, Otega Ogra, responds to Atiku’s proposal by arguing Nigeria already tested a production-subsidy arrangement while Atiku was vice-president, and that the outcome was “shambolic.” Ogra says the NNPC increased domestic crude allocation to local refineries on preferential terms by 2002, but he argues refinery utilisation later collapsed and the arrangement did not reduce petrol prices. He cites refinery utilisation figures across Warri, Kaduna and Port Harcourt, and says the plan was cancelled by an Obasanjo administration directive in 2003.

Atiku, according to the reports, frames his policy as supporting domestic refining rather than subsidising imported petrol. While Vanguard and Nigerian Eye both report the presidency’s view that the earlier approach did not work, they present the same thrust of the debate: whether the earlier preferential crude concept produced measurable improvements in refining performance and consumer prices.