Harish Salve, legal adviser to Tata entities, says the “real issue” in the Tata Trusts-related dispute is not a board meeting, but an objection connected to the Trusts’ listing. He argues that the focus should be on regulatory requirements and how they apply to the Trusts.

Salve also discusses the Reserve Bank of India’s stance. He says that in 2019, the RBI indicated that companies with access to public funds could, in some circumstances, remain outside the “upper-layer” framework. He adds that the RBI later reconsidered that position, which he frames as relevant to the current controversy.

Across the coverage provided, the differing angle is mainly the emphasis: one view presented is that the dispute is tied to procedural board-related matters, while Salve’s position is that the listing-related regulatory objection and the RBI’s evolving interpretation are the central point.