Niall Horan performs in Birmingham and honors late One Direction bandmate Liam Payne by playing a recorded voice onstage during his concert on Tuesday night. Footage described across outlets shows fans reacting emotionally during what is presented as an “End of an Era” tribute.

The reports agree on the core elements of the moment: Horan uses Payne’s recorded audio as part of his live set, framing it as a remembrance of the band and its journey. Billboard adds detail that the recording includes Payne speaking about the group’s rise and the experience shared with his bandmates in One Direction. Other outlets focus more on the audience’s visible reactions and the emotional tone of the tribute.

Overall, the coverage centers on the same onstage gesture—Horan bringing Payne’s voice back during a specific tribute segment—while differing mainly in how much they emphasize the concert setting versus the content of the audio.