Apple TV+ releases a comedy featuring Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson as brothers in a story built around a rumor that they are half-brothers. Both sources describe the premise as playful and centered on the duo’s on-screen chemistry.

Reviewers differ in how they judge the execution. TIME characterizes the series as disjointed but ultimately likable, noting that it relies on charm even when the plot feels scattered. The Post also describes “Brothers” as having multiple ideas, but says the show can feel messy and aimless, with humor landing only at times. Both outlets focus on the pair’s performances and how they inform the tone, including elements that portray the stars as caricatures of themselves.

Taken together, the reviews present “Brothers” as an Apple comedy that leans on the lead actors’ charisma while balancing a premise that leads to a frequently uneven structure.