Multiple outlets report that allegations by U.S. President Donald Trump that white people are being persecuted in South Africa are being challenged and denied. PBS NewsHour reports that Trump said he expanded the number of refugee places available for white South Africans, citing what he described as “recent increases in the incitement of racially motivated violence.” Other coverage characterizes those claims as not supported in the way Trump presents them, and highlights that statements about persecution are contested by critics who dispute the premise and the evidence behind them.

In addition to focusing on Trump’s justification for the policy change, the reporting also underscores that claims about racially motivated violence and persecution in South Africa are complex and are often framed differently by different groups, depending on sources and definitions. Overall, the accounts converge on the idea that the specific assertion that white people are uniquely being targeted is disputed and that authorities and commentators do not accept the claim as stated.