“Gareth Southgate: Changing the Game for Young Men” is a BBC documentary featuring the former England manager as he spends time with schoolboys who are portrayed as needing support and male mentorship. Reviewers describe the programme as warm and reassuring, and note that Southgate’s personal involvement and approachable manner are central to its tone. However, several critics argue that the film does not provide enough depth or analysis of the wider causes of boys’ difficulties. The Guardian says the documentary treats social problems as stemming from broader political choices, but that it does not engage with those underlying decisions, instead moving quickly to smaller, practical interventions. The Independent likewise criticises the documentary for lacking real scrutiny and nuance, describing it as a one-off programme that does not sufficiently examine issues beyond its comforting framing. Across the reviews, the emphasis is on Southgate’s sincerity and connection with participants, paired with concern that the programme’s perspective limits how far it can address systemic drivers of the challenges faced by young men in Britain.
Southgate documentary explores mentoring for young men, with reviewers citing limited scrutiny
“Gareth Southgate: Changing the Game for Young Men” is a BBC documentary featuring the former England manager as he spends time with schoolboys who are portrayed as needing support and male mentorship...
- The documentary features former England manager Gareth Southgate mentoring and spending time with schoolboys.
- Reviewers describe the tone as heartfelt and reassuring.
- Critics say the programme does not offer enough scrutiny or nuance.
- The Guardian argues the film identifies broader causes but avoids deeper engagement with political choices.
- Overall assessments are mixed, praising Southgate’s approach while questioning the depth of analysis.
The former England manager is heartfelt as he spends time with schoolboys in need of a male mentor. But the limitations on what he can change are deeply frustratingEarly on in his documentary, Changing the Game for Young Men, in that relaxed introductory section where the famous host is at home, fondling mementoes and chatting about their life, Gareth Southgate reveals he was unsure what to do next when he stopped being England football manager. Many of his admirers wish he would enter politics: they dream of him being a witty, kind presence in Westminster, a compassionate antidote to liars and clowns.Southgate has so far demurred, and here we glimpse what he may do instead. Changing the Game, an assessment of how Britain is failing a generation of demotivated young males, is politics with a politely lower-case “p”. Every problem it identifies is the result of a big political choice, which Southgate ignores before offering a small-scale solution. It’s certainly well-meant, but its limitations are frustrating. Continue reading...
2 months agoOne-off programme lacks real scrutiny and nuance – a recurring problem with the BBC’s celebrity-led social issues documentaries
2 months ago
Gladys Knight, 82, says she will step back from performing amid health concerns
R&B singer Gladys Knight, 82, says she is easing into fewer performances and stepping back from touring. Multiple outlet...
U2 share Pogues cover for Shane MacGowan tribute album
U2 have released a cover of The Pogues’ “Yeah, Yeah, Yeah, Yeah, Yeah” ahead of an upcoming Shane MacGowan tribute album...
Indiana Fever games in August: TV and streaming info for matchups vs Tempo, Wings, Liberty, Sky
The Indiana Fever play several WNBA opponents in August, and outlets publish viewing guides with game time, TV channel,...