Retired FBI profiler claims blood evidence indicates Nancy Guthrie was alive when she is believed to be taken from her home in the Catalina Foothills area of Tucson. Both outlets report that the agent points to blood spatter found on Guthrie’s front porch as a key clue. The agent characterizes the scene as a “last stand,” describing how Guthrie may have resisted or been confronted at the threshold before a lone abductor coerced her out of the house. Fox News and the New York Post both present the agent’s view that the placement and nature of the blood spatter support the conclusion that Guthrie was not killed before the abduction. Both stories also attribute further reasoning to the profiler, including that the suspect’s actions contained mistakes, though they do not provide additional verified specifics. The reports focus on the agent’s interpretation of the physical evidence rather than on new, independently confirmed investigative findings or direct statements from law enforcement in the excerpts provided.