A constitutional law expert says the 16-vote threshold required to convict Vice President Sara Duterte in her impeachment trial may be lowered depending on how many senator-judges are actually present and participating. In an interview reported by Inquirer.net, former Integrated Bar of the Philippines (IBP) president Domingo Cayosa argues that a “fair and practical” reading of the 1987 Constitution could limit the voting pool to the senator-judges who take part in the proceedings, instead of using all 24 Senate members serving as impeachment judges. Cayosa maintains that such an approach aligns with the intent and spirit of the Constitution, which he describes as not being restrictive in this context. His view implies that the math for determining the required majority could change if the number of participating judges is fewer than the full chamber. The opinion is presented as an interpretation of constitutional provisions rather than a court ruling, and it is based on the attendance and participation of senator-judges during the trial.
Expert says impeachment conviction vote threshold could be lowered based on attendance
A constitutional law expert says the 16-vote threshold required to convict Vice President Sara Duterte in her impeachment trial may be lowered depending on how many senator-judges are actually present...
- A constitutional law expert argues the 16-vote conviction threshold in VP Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial could change.
- Former IBP president Domingo Cayosa says the relevant voting pool should include only senator-judges actively present and participating.
- He contrasts this with using all 24 Senate impeachment judges as the basis for the calculation.
- The expert frames the interpretation as “fair and practical” and consistent with the 1987 Constitution’s spirit.
- The claim is an expert legal interpretation reported by Inquirer.net, not presented as a final judicial determination.
The required 16 votes to convict Vice President Sara Duterte in her impeachment trial could be lowered based on the number of senator-judges present during the proceedings, a constitutional law expert said on Saturday. Former Integrated Bar of the Philippines (IBP) president Domingo Cayosa told the Inquirer that this is the “fair and practical” interpretation […]...Keep on reading: Ex-IBP head: Impeachment conviction vote threshold can be lowered
2 hours agoThe 16-vote threshold required to convict Vice President Sara Duterte may be lowered based on actual attendance at her impeachment trial, a constitutional law expert said on Saturday. The expert argued that the voting pool should only account for the senator-judges actively participating, rather than the total 24 seats in the chamber. In an Inquirer interview, former IBP president Domingo Cayosa argued that a “fair and practical” reading of the 1987 Constitution allows for this adjustment, noting that the spirit of the Charter is inherently “not restrictive.” “When you construe a law, the Constitution in this case, you try to […]...Keep on reading: 16-vote threshold to convict VP Duterte can be lowered — Ex-IBP head
1 day ago
U.S. launches new strikes on Iran after attacks on ships in Strait of Hormuz
The United States launches new strikes against Iran early Wednesday, citing Iranian attacks on three commercial vessels...
Pedro Sanchez condemns Rajoy over xenophobic remark about France’s World Cup team
Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez condemns xenophobic statements attributed to his conservative predecessor Mariano R...
Samsung advances Yongin chip factory start to 2029
Samsung Electronics is reportedly moving forward the start of a chip factory in Yongin, South Korea, to 2029, according...