Nigella Lawson makes her debut as a new judge on The Great British Bake Off on Tuesday night, replacing Prue Leith as the show continues on Channel 4. Multiple outlets report that viewers and critics respond strongly to her presence in the tent, describing her as warm, witty and a natural fit alongside the existing judging team.

Reviews highlighted Lawson’s supportive judging style, with some noting her gentle, quieter approach and her willingness to offer feedback to contestants. HuffPost UK and others cite praise from mainstream critics for her on-screen poise and how easily she blends with Paul Hollywood, Alison Hammond and Noel Fielding. The Mirror also reports that co-stars express awe at her arrival.

Alongside the mostly favourable reactions, at least one outlet notes mixed sentiments about the episode itself. The Daily Mail reports that while Lawson receives unanimous praise, some viewers are left frustrated by a “cop out” twist early in the series. Other coverage also mentions that some viewers view the shake-up as either a missed chance to refresh the format or a hoped-for improvement, though opinions on Lawson’s fit remain broadly positive across sources.