Phil Collins says he has finally mended a feud with Paul McCartney that lasted for about 24 years. Collins describes the dispute as stemming from an “icy” interaction between the two musicians during their appearance together at the Queen’s Golden Jubilee concert, and he now says he has reached a resolution with McCartney.

According to the accounts, Collins frames the reconciliation as following an apology from McCartney. Outlets report that McCartney apologized after Collins had criticized him for being “patronising” in their exchange. While the reports agree on the length of the feud and the broad outline of what triggered it, they differ slightly in emphasis—some focus on the original cold exchange, while others highlight that the underlying tension traces back to a long-ago misunderstanding.