United Airlines is facing a class-action lawsuit filed by passengers who say they paid premium prices for “window seats” that do not have actual windows. According to multiple reports, passengers who purchased the seats find themselves seated next to a cabin wall rather than a window. The lawsuit is directed at United, and other coverage also references Delta Air Lines in connection with similar allegations.

The airline sought to have the case dismissed, arguing that a “window seat” does not necessarily require a physical window. However, a federal judge rejects the bid to throw out the lawsuit, concluding that the plaintiffs plausibly purchased an actual window seat and were not merely buying a seat position. The judge’s decision allows the litigation to continue, setting up further proceedings over how airlines describe and sell these seats and whether that marketing is misleading under the terms alleged in the complaint.

The reports present the issue as a dispute over seat labeling and customer expectations rather than a claim about airline safety.